Who was the bigger All-star snub, Michael Pineda or C.C. Sabathia?

Their stats are pretty even but, Pineda's stats would be better if he played on a team that could score. I'm going to be biased on this and say Pineda is the bigger snub because I'm a big Mariners fan and Pineda's stats would be better if he was on a high market winning team like the Yankees or Red Sox.